Chip Stocks CRASHING & BURNING. I'm Not Buying Yet
Chip stocks fell 10.7% on November 20 after reports that the SEC is examining Nvidia's accounting and that Google cut Broadcom chip orders. Why I'd wait for Broadcom's December 9 results.
TL;DR
- The PHLX Semiconductor Index fell 10.73% on Friday, November 20, to 8,408.59. That is its fifth-worst day since 1994. The second-worst was 12.25% on November 5, so two of the index's five worst days have come in the past three weeks.
- Two reports hit the biggest chip companies on the same day. Reuters reported that the SEC is examining Nvidia's accounting, and an analyst said Google cut its 2027 orders for Broadcom-designed AI chips by about 20%. Investors also expect the Fed to raise interest rates on December 9, which makes AI data centers costlier to finance.
- Nvidia fell 14.0% to $125.53, Broadcom 12.2% and Micron 13.9%. The index is now 42.5% below its June 22 record close.
- I am not buying chip stocks yet. Anyone who bought on November 10, after the first crash, is down 15.9% in eight trading days. The next earnings reports come on fixed dates: Dell on November 24, Marvell on December 1, and Broadcom on December 9, the day of the Fed's rate decision.
- My trigger is Broadcom's results on December 9. Broadcom forecast $21.7 billion of AI chip revenue for the quarter to October. If its forecast for the quarter to January is higher, I'd buy the AI chip makers. I'd buy memory makers like Micron last.
More on AI & Semiconductors: Jensen Huang Resigns as Nvidia CEO: What It Means for NVDA Stock Before the November 17 Results →
The Board
Regular-session closes on November 20 against November 19, with each stock's fall from its 2026 record close. Source: Yahoo Finance daily data.
Why Are Chip Stocks Down Today?
Chip stocks fell because two bad reports landed on Nvidia and Broadcom, the two most important AI chip companies, this morning - in a sector already down by a third from its summer high.
The first was about Nvidia's accounting. Reuters reported that the Securities and Exchange Commission is examining Nvidia's accounting, per its report on Investing.com. Reuters could not say when the inquiry began or which accounting issues it covers, and neither the SEC nor Nvidia commented. A question about how NVDA's profits are counted hits every chip stock - especially with NVDA's circular financing a common topic among AI bears for some time now. Nvidia has agreed to invest up to $100 billion in OpenAI and up to $10 billion in Anthropic, and both have committed to buy Nvidia systems, per Nvidia's own announcements. Critics call this circular: part of the money Nvidia invests comes back to it as chip revenue. Reuters did not say whether the SEC's inquiry touches these deals.
The second was about Google's orders. Analyst Ming-Chi Kuo said his checks of Google's suppliers show it cutting about 1 million units, roughly 20%, from its 2027 orders for the Broadcom-designed TPU 8i chip, and planning more of a MediaTek-designed version, per StockAnalysis and 24/7 Wall St. Neither Google nor Broadcom has confirmed it. This is about more than the size of the cut. This is the first report from one of the biggest chip buyers ordering fewer chips for next year - the first signal of slowing demand. And the market is always forward looking. With chip stocks priced for perfection, the market is now repricing future earnings.
Signs of slowing demand for AI chips triggered today's selloff, and expected Fed rate rises aren't helping. The 10-year Treasury yield actually fell today, to 4.91% from 5.05%, as our heatmap's market row shows. Wednesday's Fed minutes said almost all officials expect more rate rises, and Fed Governor Lisa Cook said on Friday that markets strongly expect a quarter-point rise at the December 8-9 meeting, per CNBC. Higher rates raise the cost of borrowing to build data centers, and the companies building them are especially exposed, because they spend heavily up front and many lose money for years before they make any.
The rest of the market fell less. The S&P 500 closed down 3.7% and the Nasdaq Composite 5.3%, while Walmart, Costco and Procter & Gamble rose (staples/defensives), per our heatmap. The S&P 500 is now 11.6% below its October 6 record close, which counts as a correction. Anthropic, which listed on Thursday, fell about 9% to $88.91, still above its $83 offer price.
How Friday Ranks: Two of the Five Worst Days Since 1994 Came This Month
| Rank | Date | PHLX Semiconductor Index, one day |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | March 16, 2020 | -15.90% |
| 2 | November 5, 2026 | -12.25% |
| 3 | April 14, 2000 | -11.64% |
| 4 | March 12, 2020 | -10.91% |
| 5 | November 20, 2026 | -10.73% |
Close-to-close moves, ranked by Regards of Wallstreet from Yahoo Finance daily closes for the index since 1994.
The bounces after November 5 did not last. The index rose 4.2% on November 6 and 6.9% on November 9. Goldman Sachs analyst James Schneider called the sector "clearly in oversold territory" in a note covered on November 10, and named Nvidia, Broadcom and AMD as his picks, per TradeZero's summary. And now we're 15.9% below that day's close.
Each rally since November 5 has faded within days, and that is my main reason for waiting. The rallies on November 6, 9 and 11 show how fast this sector can bounce, so selling on the worst day of November 5 meant selling near a short-term low. But each rally crashed back down within days, because nothing causing the selling changed. Friday added two new reasons to drop.
Why Low Price-to-Earnings Ratios Are Not a Reason to Buy Right Now
On the numbers, these stocks look cheap. Nvidia earned $2.68 a share in its latest quarter. Counted four times over, that is $10.72, so at $125.53 the shares trade at about 11.7 times earnings. Micron forecast $38.15 a share for the quarter to December 3. That is $152.60 a year at that pace, so at $594.51 it trades at about 3.9 times. SanDisk forecast $55 to $57 a share for its current quarter, per its October 29 release. That forecast was counted before its 8-for-1 stock split took effect on Friday. That is about $7 a share after the split, or $28 a year at that pace, so at $79.24 it trades at about 2.8 times.
The ratio is only as good as the earnings under it, and chip earnings swing much more than chip sales. A chip maker's biggest costs, its factories and its engineers, stay the same whether it sells more or less. So when sales fall, profits fall faster. A Bank of America scenario published around November 6 put numbers on it: a 20% cut to AI spending in 2027 could reduce chip makers' sales by more than 20% and their earnings per share by 35% to 40%, per a Placera report on the note. That is a scenario, not Bank of America's forecast. Applied to Nvidia, a 35% cut to earnings would turn about 11.7 times into about 18 times.
Memory makers' earnings carry the most risk. Micron's forecast of $61.5 billion of revenue for the quarter to December 3 is 4.5 times the $13.64 billion it reported for the same quarter a year earlier, as our Micron tracker records. Memory prices rise and fall with the balance of supply and demand, so a memory maker's profits rise and fall faster than anyone else's in the sector. The bull case is real: Micron says supply will be tighter in 2027 and 2028 than this year and that it has committed more than 75% of its 2027 output, per Computerworld. My view is that a stock trading at about 3.9 times a record forecast is pricing that record to be the peak, and Friday's Google report makes the market more convinced the peak is behind it. Micron is 51.0% below its June 25 record close and SanDisk is 72.9% below its own.
Nvidia at About 12 Times Earnings: Cheap Only If the Earnings Hold Up
Nvidia closed at $125.53, down 14.0% on the day and 22.9% on the week. It is 27.7% below its $173.73 close on November 11, the day before Jensen Huang resigned as chief executive.
Its last report was strong. Revenue of $115.8 billion was about double a year earlier. Its forecast for the January quarter came in above what analysts expected, as our page on Huang's resignation records. The shares fell anyway, because the questions are about the company and not the quarter. Nvidia still has no permanent CEO. Its board has not published the findings of its investigation into the reports about Huang. And now an SEC inquiry into its accounting has been reported.
An SEC inquiry often ends without any enforcement action, as Reuters noted. I'd still not buy Nvidia on its price-to-earnings ratio until the scope of the inquiry is known. The inquiry is about the earnings figure that ratio depends on. Circular financing is a real risk.
Nvidia's two largest investments in its own customers: OpenAI, announced September 22, 2025, and Anthropic, announced November 18, 2025. The OpenAI deal is a non-binding letter of intent. Both are recorded in our AI Compute Deal Ledger.
Upcoming Dates That Could Show Whether Chip Stocks Have Bottomed
Each of these dates will show whether the biggest buyers of AI chips are still placing orders. Our earnings calendar carries the confirmed times.
- Tuesday, November 24: Dell reports after the close. Analysts expect adjusted EPS of $6.59 on $49.2 billion of revenue. Dell builds the servers that AI chips go into, so its orders are the nearest read on whether data center buyers are still spending.
- Thursday, November 26: US markets are closed for Thanksgiving, and Friday, November 27 closes early at 1:00pm ET.
- Tuesday, December 1: Marvell reports after the close, with its conference call at 4:30pm ET, per Marvell's announcement. Marvell designs custom AI chips for cloud companies, the same business as the Google work Broadcom is reported to be losing.
- Wednesday, December 9: the Fed decision at 2:00pm ET, then Broadcom after the close. Our December Fed hub has the odds of a quarter-point and a half-point rise. Broadcom's forecast for AI chip revenue in the quarter to January is the first company answer to the Google report. On November 19, before Friday's fall, options priced a move of about 13.5% either way for Broadcom after its results.
- Around Wednesday, December 16: Micron reports. That date is an estimate from earnings calendars; Micron has not confirmed it.
Our Call: I'm Not Buying Chip Stocks Before December 9, and Memory Comes Last
My call is that the chip index closes on December 10, the day after Broadcom reports, below its November 20 close. I'd expect any rally before December 9 to fade the way the November 6, 9 and 11 rallies did. The two questions Friday raised, Nvidia's accounting and Google's orders, have no answer before then.
Broadcom's December 9 forecast could change my mind. Broadcom forecast $21.7 billion of AI chip revenue for the quarter to October. If on December 9 it forecasts more than that for the quarter to January, that would contradict the Google report with a number from the company that sells the chips. On that forecast I'd buy the AI chip makers, starting with Broadcom.
I'd buy memory chip makers like Micron last. I would not buy Micron before its own December report. Its earnings are the most exposed to a cut in spending, and its shares will move with any sign of one.
These predictions are recorded in our public Track Record, which grades them later. The author holds no securities.
Predictions Logged in Our Track Record
| # | Stance | Call | Entry | Graded on | Conviction |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bearish | SOXX (iShares Semiconductor ETF) closes below its November 20 close | $123.40, Nov 20 close | December 10, 2026 close | 6/10 |
| 2 | Conditional long | Broadcom, only if its December 9 forecast for AI chip revenue in the quarter to January is above $21.7 billion | None until the forecast, then the December 10 open | January 8, 2027 close | 5/10 |
| 3 | Pass | Not buying Micron before its December report | $594.51, Nov 20 close | December 18, 2026 close | 6/10 |
What Would Prove Me Wrong
- The iShares Semiconductor ETF (SOXX) closes higher on December 10 than on November 20. If it closes above $123.40, call 1 is wrong.
- Nvidia says what the SEC is examining. A statement from Nvidia describing a limited inquiry, or a permanent CEO named before December 9, would take away one of the two reasons to wait.
- The Fed signals that December is its last rise. That would lower the cost of money for data center builders and lift the price investors will pay for future profits.
- Micron rises above $594.51 by December 18. Then the pass on Micron was the wrong call.
The One-Line Read
Chip stocks fell 10.7% on reports about Nvidia's accounting and Google's orders, the second double-digit fall in three weeks. I'd wait for Broadcom's December 9 forecast before buying, and buy memory makers last.
Next up:PCE inflation, Wednesday at 8:30am ET →
More on AI & Semiconductors
Updated Every Saturday
The Week Ahead
Every earnings date, Fed event and setup for the current trading week, on one page.
Refreshed Weekly
Earnings Calendar
Who reports next, when, and what consensus and the whisper expect.
The Week-Ahead Brief
Don’t miss next week’s setups. Get the Sunday brief.
Every Sunday: next week’s earnings dates, Fed days and the trades worth watching, from the same desk that writes the week-ahead hub. Free, built for retail investors.